B. asks: How does one go about helping someone recognize that they need help?My brother had a brain tumor removed in March. He has made an astounding physical recovery, but has
now somehow slipped into a dark well of anger, possibly depression – who knows? He’s not talking about what’s going on in his head.Granted, some of this may have physical/neurological roots and the doctors say it can take some time for those to improve, but the guys at work seem to think he’s acting just like before. At home however, his behavior is destroying his marriage.
Thanks for any words of wisdom you can offer.
Dear B,
What I can offer are some ideas based on my training. The real wisdom is more likely to come out of you. After seeking ideas here and elsewhere, take the ideas into your heart and compare them to what you know about your brother, the family, and the situation, and do what your heart tells you is right. In the depths of your loving heart–that’s where the real wisdom is.
Helping another person realize something that they’re not seeing is tricky, because usually they are choosing not to see it. They want to see life the way that they are seeing it, and usually for a good reason. The truth is too scary or ugly or painful, and they’d really rather not go there. Who would? For that reason, a big part of a success is reducing the person’s fear and emotional pain as much as you can–while still getting the bitter pill down.
I would recommend getting together your sister-in-law and any other family and friends that have witnessed your brother’s dysfunction, and who love him firmly. Have dinner together. Have someone (chosen for his/her influence with him) lead out by explaining that part of the reason for the dinner was to give everyone a chance to express their love to your brother. One by one, go around the table and share your positive feelings to him–happy memories, admirable traits, your happiness that his surgery went well, etc. After the last person speaks, the leader could invite your brother to say a few words. The next part of the dinner is unscripted, with the lead person deciding how to proceed based on your brother’s comments. Possibly your brother will express feelings of unworthiness because he has been so angry lately. If he gives an opening like that, the lead person can acknowledge that s/he has noticed his change of demeanor; the others present can affirm this also. The lead person can then say something about how it has been hard on him/her seeing your brother so unhappy, and that s/he would like to help him find greater happiness. Others can echo the sentiment. Someone should say at this point that they have read somewhere (like here) that in cases like this, both counseling and medicine are likely to be helpful. Someone else should have the name/number of a counselor or counseling center handy (homework done beforehand). Your brother may be taking medication already, and possibly part of what he is experiencing is a side effect of that medication, so a straight-up talk with the doc is in order to either change medications or add a new medication to help. The point is that your brother feels that he has a lot of people who care about him and want to help him.
If your brother gives a gracious ‘acceptance of love’ speech without giving an easy opportunity to slide into the next topic, the lead person gets to decide how to proceed. S/he might decide that it is best just to finish dinner and take up the topic another time. If things are going smoothly, the next step might be to have someone invite his wife to speak about what it has been like for her, with her husband’s recovery. Then she can start into the part about noticing a change in his personality and how that’s been hard for her to see because she loves him and hates to see him so unhappy. And then you’re on your way.
Here’s hoping things get better for your brother and for the family.
Best wishes,
Mr. C.