Try, try again
I saw this rain-ruined crocus the other day, and thought to myself, better a broken flower than an empty patch of ground.
I don’t ask that anyone succeed in all they do– but I do ask that they try. This is the key to my relationships with people—I can’t be around quitters, or people too cowardly to try in the first place. Better to try and fail, than to never know if you could have succeeded.
My obsession with trying stems directly from my observations of my parents’ behavior. My mother gave up on her Ph.D., gave up on working, gave up on being independent, gave up on her health and attractiveness, gave up on being forgiving. My dad tried and failed to stop drinking for a long time; he tried and failed to get his temper under control—but eventually, when he bottomed out after being arrested, losing his driver’s license, and losing his job, he tried some more. Eventually, he succeeded. First, he stopped smoking and drinking. Then, he started going to A.A. Then, he got two jobs below his abilities, so he could pay our child support. Then he began trying harder to present a more pleasant face to the world, and to overcome his misanthropic tendencies. Meanwhile, my mother, a pretty, smart, ordained minister with a promising career as a lecturer on women’s issues in the church, allowed herself to become obese, increasingly crippled by the obesity (no outdoor family activities with her), and welfare-dependent– yet she continuously harped upon my father for putting her in this position, while somehow missing that they’d been divorced for ten years, and she could try to do whatever she wanted.
Obviously, my perspective is my own, flawed, and I am not as sympathetic to my mother as I would like to be. But the fact remains that older I get, the less sorry I felt for my mother, and the more I appreciate my father’s attempts to be a better person. That I got my bipolar in a double shot from both parents makes the contrast in possibilities, in attempts at success, even starker. But Dad finally pulled past his own pathologies, and worked long and hard to improve. I never really saw my mother trying, although she’d talk a good game, and did manage to do the minimum, working as a substitute teacher just enough (never full time, never every day) to earn what child support didn’t supply each month, when it became clear she wasn’t going to win the lottery (or an increase in child support) anytime soon. However, as soon as my grandparents died and her brief teaching pension vested, she stopped even that– and now lives a life of complete leisure in Southern California. I say that sarcastically, but still– she’s clearly got more disposable spending money than we do on a month to month basis.
I am always going to resent her—for not even trying. She did not try to shelter us from poverty. She did not try to get help for her own mental state in order to do best by us. She did not even try to think about her own mental state in order to recognize she needed help. She was too focused on being the victim. (I suppose that’s what makes her a narcissist.) She did have unloving and harsh parents, and she had to work at the family business—but she also had loving sisters and many friends in high school, and that family job paid for college. Yet the focus is always on the negative, unless she’s feeling ignored in a social situation, when she gets grandiose and bragging. My father’s mother was not the most loving or uncritical of women, either, and he had to become the “man of the house” at age 13 when his father died. So I don’t know where she got off whining about the tough childhood—certainly, she never had to endure the humiliation my brother and I did of being called to the front of the classroom to get our free lunch tickets as my brother and I did, or being mocked by other kids for wearing the same five outfits, week in and out, all school year long.
My dad doesn’t try to be a parent now. He just wants to spend time with me. He is constantly trying to make amends, even though I’ve long since forgiven him. I worry about his getting older, and his untreated depression, but he knows enough now that if he got really bad, I think he would do something about it.
My mom, however, still tries to parent me. She urges me to finish all the food on the plate, despite the fact that her obesity as a model of my biological fate makes me sick to my stomach. She tells me what to do. She interrupts constantly to relate her opinion. She never listens to any professional legal advice I have to give her, only when she asks. In short, she has no respect for me as an adult. No conception, I suppose, because her narcisissm dictates how she re-writes the stories I burst in upon.
I tried to forgive and to understand her perspective, but I can’t understand how she could be so smart and yet so damaged that she is unable to make up her mind to get better. So what do I do? I tried to keep my mouth shut and my temper in check. For a while, I was getting better at it. I didn’t erupt, insult or ignore as much as I once did. And I tried not to take it so personally; realizing that her failure to try has nothing to do with my worthiness, or lack thereof. I failed, and we’re not speaking anymore, but I think I tried.
April 14th, 2008 at 8:50 am
You tried. You can’t help it if the listener takes all the love and caring you give and can’t feel or hear it – this is one of the things I struggle with in my relationship with my husband. There are many, many times when I wish he could hear me and all he hears are voices from the past. It’s so hard, sometimes.
*hugs*
April 14th, 2008 at 10:26 am
You put up the good fight.
People born of your circumstances don’t generally have the drive, backbone, resilience, or wherewithal to fight like you’ve done. You did your best. You can feel good about that.
April 14th, 2008 at 11:58 am
You’ve accurately described everything I’ve felt about my sister. Kudos to your dad–it just shows that we all have free will and the choice to make our life better, no matter how our genetics traps us.
April 14th, 2008 at 6:31 pm
Today is my mother’s birthday, although I will not be calling to wish her a happy one because I stopped communicating with her many years ago. Instead I sent out a silent prayer for her, because to communicate with her directly would bring harm to me and my family. Is today your mother’s birthday? Because I think we have the same mother.
I don’t believe in coincidence. Try, try again. Posted on April 14. What a wild ride life is.
April 14th, 2008 at 8:54 pm
I stopped speaking to my father for nearly two years after a similar set of circumstances. And while I was ready to just walk away, it turned out that he wasn’t. So, even though it took almost losing me to make him realize it, I wanted to say that it can happen. You’ve tried. Now it’s her turn.
April 15th, 2008 at 9:54 am
this post nearly knocked me over. you described my mother to a T. it’s 39 years later, and she still blames my birth father for her issues. my birth father isn’t sober, still suffers from his mental illness but he’s owned up to his faults, made amends and like your experience, doesn’t try to parent me. he just wants to have his kids in his life knowing he missed out for so many years.
i have more respect for a person who can be honest with themselves, and make amends and like you make the needed changes.
my mother used to beat us severely, yet no apologies or even an acknowledgment that she made mistakes. (a positive aspect of this is that i own up to my “stuff” with my children, and do better.)
i am in shock over the similarities, down to the free lunches and wearing the same clothes. it reminded me of a comment my step-dad gave me on an outfit. he said, “that is so pretty you should wear it again tomorrow.” and i did. he was my only saving grace growing up in our house.
this is a beautiful post that you’ve written, and it isn’t b/c i relate so much to your story.
the whole of it just flows beautifully. i bow to your beautiful craft, my friend.
xo,
moonflower
April 16th, 2008 at 1:10 am
It takes an amazing amount of strength and courage to plough on through difficult circumstances,through failures, when success looks bleak, which you know very well. Some people can look at in that light, others, simply give-up.
I wonder, if you have tried to forgive your mom….to just let go of all the past hurt and pain you feel? That was my greatest triumph, despite how many times I tried and failed at it. The day I let go of all that hate, that pain, was the day I could look at my mom in a different light. She screwed up…a lot. She did a lot of damage. It’s not something I will ever be able to forget. What I can do, is change my reaction to it, now. I’m not a helpless little kid caught up in all of it anymore. It feels so much lighter releasing that pain. And through it, I realized that truly, the only one I was hurting by holding it all in, was me. It doesn’t hurt nearly so much, anymore.
April 16th, 2008 at 4:21 pm
This is a very moving post. Thank you so much for posting it.
April 19th, 2008 at 1:39 pm
I have big issues with the same thing- my mom does the exact same thing. For almost twenty years she has blamed my dad for a lot of stuff, but her new favorite is to blame her diagnosis of bipolar for all of her shortcomings. I tried to explain to her that just because there is a reason why many things are a challenge to her, that’s not a reason to stop trying to help herself. In fact, I told her that knowing the source of many of her challenges gives her a greater responsibility to treat it.
May 5th, 2008 at 1:04 pm
The symbolism is so intense and poignant here. So moving. Thank you. z